Discussion about this post

User's avatar
form and pattern's avatar

I'm curious where your impression of IPF has come from, because to me (as someone who's been doing facilitated IPF for a bit more than half a year) it feels like you're arguing against a strawman. IPFP ≈ RPFP, IME.

My experience is that doing this practice brings up pretty rough memories and emotions–it hurts! Because hard psychic material is the stuff that blocks to learning secure functioning are made from. Maybe if someone was doing it without a facilitator, it could be bypassy, but the people I've introduced to Dan Brown's guided meditations on YouTube pretty uniformly end up thinking back to real difficult situations they haven't finished digesting yet, and they found it hard going...

Anyway, for me it's been anti-bypassy. I've not experienced an increase in blaming my parents, kinda the opposite: I've gotten in touch with the ways that I blame others reflexively and don't take responsibility for myself. I've felt through more raw grief and shame than I was really prepared for. And of course, in the end, the reason I'm doing it is to show up with more capacity and responsibility in the real relationships I have, which seems to be happening, slowly. In the end it's targeted meditative therapy, building a safe-ish container and then triggering me repeatedly, and helping me to imagine different possibilities for what could happen and how might I act differently.

The thing about methodological nuclear family-ism you mention ("grieving our attachment wounds not as a result of our parents’ individual failings, but as a shared burden that they have carried before us"), I don't think that's real either. IPF doesn't take a position on where the burden comes from–because the practice is to imagine new possibilities. The material that comes up for me while doing that is sometimes about my real parents, but it's also about my friends and lovers (or exes of either type). And I wonder quite a lot about everyone's family histories in that process too...

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts